What's your Jewish volume?

i like the idea of moving away from affiliated/unaffiliated. its a troublesome bianary. i see a pair of problems with “volume”
*it’s linear
*it is unclear how one would use the scale to describe oneself. it is fairly clear how tied one is to jewish institutions. though it might not be clear to other people it is a reasonably uncontentious fact and knowable. once you get into how people feel measurment is quite difficult. many people with low levels of religiosity likely rate their jewish volumes ahead of folks with higher degrees of religioisty and vice versa. this is not inherently problematic. it seems that in general people, especially funder, are more interested in jewish behavior than identity. ID is important insofar as it influences behavior but not as important by itself.

all this to say, mazal tov on beating back the beast of affiliation/non-affiliation.